businessman, consulting, business-2606509.jpg

Loyalty Funnel

In a world teeming with an estimated 12 to 24 million e-commerce businesses vying for the attention of consumers, it’s the customers who wield unprecedented purchasing power. Brands, both large and small, find themselves grappling to secure their slice of the market. Yet, the challenge doesn’t merely lie in enticing new customers to make a purchase; it extends to the art of bringing existing customers back into the fold.

In this fiercely competitive landscape, it is customer retention that must take precedence over customer acquisition, a strategic shift that ensures cost-effectiveness while simultaneously driving profit margins. The significance of this shift is underscored by the fact that a modest 5% improvement in customer retention can result in a staggering 25% boost in profits. Conversely, acquiring a new customer can cost as much as five times more than the endeavor to re-engage an existing one.

In a nutshell, focusing on customer loyalty is not just about fostering goodwill; it’s about the very sustenance and growth of businesses. In this extensive exploration, we’ll dive deep into the world of customer loyalty, unraveling its manifold benefits, delving into best practices, and charting a course for building and maintaining customer loyalty at every stage of the customer journey.

The Benefits of Customer Loyalty

1. Increases Average Order Value (AOV), Customer Lifetime Value (LTV), and Return on Investment (ROI)

When it comes to metrics that underscore profitability, brands should have their sights trained on Average Order Value (AOV), Customer Lifetime Value (LTV), and Return on Investment (ROI). Acquiring new customers often necessitates hefty investments, as marketing and sales teams deploy substantial resources to identify, target, and convince potential leads to engage with the brand. What compounds the challenge is the absence of guarantees that the initial purchase will translate into recurrent business.

However, with the right approach, brands can successfully entice their existing customer base to make subsequent purchases. For instance, they can employ strategies like up-selling and cross-selling, based on a customer’s purchase history. Such approaches encourage existing customers to return for additional transactions, thereby driving up AOV.

Points-based loyalty programs, in particular, emerge as a highly effective strategy for stimulating repeat purchases. These programs offer brands a legitimate reason to maintain ongoing connections with their customers, extending incentives like complimentary products in exchange for further purchases. The allure of earning rewards through continued patronage acts as a potent incentive for customers to return, not just to redeem these points but also to engage more deeply with the brand.

Loyalty programs invariably also lead to an increase in repeat AOV. Customers, enticed by discounts and rewards, often end up spending more, even after applying these benefits. They may opt for larger quantities or higher-priced products, thus driving the average order value higher.

To illustrate, a prominent beauty and wellness brand witnessed an approximate 30% surge in AOV for loyalty-driven purchases compared to the overall pool of transactions. This increment was largely underpinned by a substantial 50% rise in basket size, a phenomenon attributed to the point-based discounts.

It’s worth noting that the costs associated with creating and maintaining such incentives are typically more economical than those incurred through paid advertising campaigns and other promotional strategies. Furthermore, existing customers tend to be more lucrative, being 50% more likely to experiment with new products and spending a noteworthy 31% more than their new counterparts. The development of robust relationships with loyal customers presents an economical avenue for achieving improvements in AOV, LTV, and ROI over time.

2. Builds Meaningful Relationships and Drives New Business

Loyalty initiatives, such as exclusive offers and rewards programs, lay the foundation for deeper and more meaningful relationships with customers. Such connections are pivotal in building trust, nurturing repeat purchases, and triggering the desired conversions, all of which contribute to the improvement of metrics like AOV and ROI.

In cases where brands fail to establish these relationships with their customers, they might also struggle with the perceived lack of credibility. Loyal customers play a pivotal role in crafting social proof – a phenomenon where people actively seek reviews and recommendations prior to making a purchase decision. Statistics underscore the significance of this: 95% of consumers confess to reading reviews while shopping, and a staggering 8 out of 10 shoppers browse online reviews even while they’re physically inside a store. Such reviews prove especially persuasive when they are accompanied by photos or videos illustrating the product in real-world scenarios.

In a broader context, loyal customers contribute to the creation of a community. This community often takes the form of customers communicating and expressing their affection for a brand through social media channels and word-of-mouth. These customers act as advocates who attract new business with no additional investment from the brand itself.

3. Captures Valuable Feedback and Nurtures Product Innovation

The task of convincing first-time shoppers to remain engaged following their initial purchase can be a formidable one, whether the aim is to gather reviews, referrals, or subsequent transactions. However, brands that invest their efforts in nurturing strong relationships with their customers stand to gain access to a treasure trove of valuable information.

Once trust is established, brands can continually solicit reviews and ratings, conduct surveys, and encourage the creation of user-generated content. This wealth of data becomes the backbone for fine-tuning branding, product offerings, and customer service. According to Google, a remarkable 92% of leading marketers endorse the usage of data for understanding consumer preferences as a crucial aspect of their growth strategies.

For instance, positive reviews regarding product quality can guide brands in their content strategies. Negative reviews, accompanied by images of products damaged during shipping, enable brands to address these issues directly. By embracing transparency and fostering direct communication, brands signal their commitment to customer satisfaction. Additionally, customer suggestions for new features or products serve as invaluable inputs that brands can take into consideration. This ongoing feedback loop not only bolsters trust but also deepens the customer’s connection with the brand.

Best Practices for Customer Loyalty

1. Take an Omnichannel Approach

Brands need to be where their customers are, which means engaging through various channels such as email, text messages, social media, and physical stores. This necessitates the adoption of an omnichannel approach, where brands craft seamless experiences across all marketing channels, aiming to reduce friction and churn.

To ensure the effectiveness of an omnichannel strategy, brands should focus on three core aspects:

Identify where, why, and how customers interact with the brand and its products. This involves understanding customer preferences, whether they are active on social media, have a proclivity for SMS over email, seek a mobile app, or simply need a more responsive website.

Offer consistent messaging, content, and support across all channels. Customers should not be required to shift from their preferred communication channel to access the information or experiences they desire.

Research and invest in the right marketing stack to guarantee unified communication. This entails the search for tools that integrate seamlessly across different aspects of a brand’s online presence, including the website, social media accounts, email and SMS platforms, and more.

2. Focus on Personalization

Recognizing the unique nature of each customer and their varied motivations is fundamental to driving loyalty. No two customers or brands are identical, and a one-size-fits-all approach to loyalty may not be sufficient.

Brands must create a loyalty program that offers a balanced mix of actions and rewards tailored to their specific goals and the motivations of their customers. Such programs typically involve customers earning points for activities such as creating an account, making a purchase, or writing a product review. Some advanced platforms, such as Stamped, allow brands to create custom events, providing points in accordance with seasonal trends, exclusive events, and more. The rewards offered commonly encompass discounts, free shipping, and birthday gifts, all of which play a vital role in boosting sales, engagement, and customer satisfaction. According to Google, 90% of leading marketers attest to the significant contribution of personalization to business profitability.

3. Reward High-Value Customers

While the ultimate goal is to nurture loyalty across the customer spectrum, brands can find a strong starting point by focusing their attention on their most devoted customers. These high-value customers aren’t exclusively those who spend the most but also those who actively promote the brand, driving new business.

To reward high-value customers, brands can incorporate VIP tiers and referrals into their loyalty programs. VIP tiers can incentivize customers to increase their spending or earn more points, allowing them to unlock enhanced perks. For example, when customers amass 1,000 points, they ascend to a higher tier and become eligible for free shipping on all subsequent purchases.

Referral programs, on the other hand, encourage customers to recommend the brand to their friends, thereby fostering new customer acquisition. Brands often reward this behavior with incentives such as a $5 discount for every successful referral. Referral marketing emerges as an incredibly efficient means of leveraging existing customers to attract new ones, as people are 90% more likely to trust and buy from a brand if it has been recommended by a friend. Moreover, referral marketing is usually associated with a low customer acquisition cost since the majority of the legwork is performed by customers themselves.

The reward system for high-value customers, including referral programs, consistently drives repeat purchases and bolsters the AOV. For instance, a leading beauty brand witnessed an AOV of $53 and an average basket size of 5.0 due to referral redemptions (from new customers), compared to an overall AOV of $38 and an average basket size of 4.1, all achieved through their referral program powered by Stamped. Impressively, they amassed $65,000 in revenue over a three-month period solely from referrals and referrers.

4. Capture and Leverage Customer Data

Data-driven insights represent the cornerstone of understanding what works and what needs improvement, whether that pertains to popular products or the effectiveness of rewards. While brands are often privy to vast troves of customer data, some may not fully harness its potential. To unlock the true value of this data, brands must go beyond mere collection and reporting, finding ways to integrate it into their strategies.

In the context of loyalty, brands can start by examining their best and worst products based on engagement, sales, and inventory. From there, they can collaborate with brand advocates to promote their less popular products or offer limited-time incentives that award double the points for purchasing surplus items. It is imperative that brands continuously monitor and refine their loyalty initiatives. For instance, are customers accumulating points without redeeming them, or are certain rewards languishing unclaimed? Such scenarios could indicate an imbalance in the points-earning system or in the perceived value of the rewards. Brands need to remain adaptable, always ready to make adjustments based on the insights gleaned from their customer data.

Lastly, brands should seek to extract more than just basic engagement and purchase data by soliciting reviews. While personal anecdotes may present challenges in terms of consolidation and analysis, they serve as invaluable resources for content creation and credibility building. Reviews and ratings, especially when accompanied by photos or videos showcasing product usage, offer rich material for paid, social, and email campaigns, and they can feature prominently on product pages and in case studies. This aspect assumes heightened significance considering that 84% of shoppers place greater trust in user-generated content as opposed to traditional advertising, thereby rendering reviews pivotal in building trust and loyalty.

Tips for Building Customer Loyalty at Every Stage of the Funnel


While the acquisition phase might appear to be too early to consider loyalty, brands can commence their journey toward loyalty by harnessing existing customers to drive new business. This approach not only provides a strong starting point with potential customers but also reduces the resources required to identify and target leads, with existing customers acting as advocates to attract new ones.

Partnerships and referrals stand out as the two most effective approaches to make loyal customers an integral component of the acquisition strategy. Brands can establish partnerships with top advocates and influencers to stimulate interest and sales, whether it is for their brand as a whole or specific products. Collaborative efforts may manifest through social campaigns, email promotions, or special sales.

For instance, a brand might collaborate with influencers to curate a selection of their favorite products, complete with a special discount code to share with their followers. The influencer’s credibility can foster a sense of loyalty among their audience even before they make their first purchase. Brands can leverage integrated solutions like Stamped’s Gatsby integration to craft custom referral codes for influencers and track the customers who generate user-generated content and tag them on Instagram and TikTok.

Referral programs play a significant role in driving both sales and loyalty. Customers acquired through referrals tend to spend 200% more and exhibit a 37% higher retention rate in comparison to the average consumer.


Building loyalty during the conversion phase centers on efforts to persuade customers to make their initial purchase decision. Existing customers can be a valuable resource in this context by highlighting store ratings, product reviews, and user-generated content.

Brands can place their best five-star review prominently on the product page, introduce a Q&A feature for customers to answer queries from other shoppers, and curate a gallery featuring users’ photos and videos. These elements of social proof and brand community create a strong sense of customer loyalty, motivating potential customers to complete their first purchase and become part of the community.

Another avenue for fostering customer loyalty at the conversion stage is by emphasizing the presence and benefits of the loyalty program. Loyalty programs should feature low or no barriers to entry, allowing customers to register and start earning points without the need for initial action. Consider offering special perks for a customer’s first purchase, such as a 10% discount on their next order. Contrary to popular belief, loyalty programs aren’t solely a re-engagement tool; they are effective in driving initial engagement as well. About 56% of consumers express a greater inclination to buy from a brand offering a loyalty program with immediate benefits.


The retention phase provides brands with numerous opportunities to nurture customer loyalty. Brands can continue to leverage advocates, referrals, reviews, and ratings, as well as user-generated content. For instance, they can request new customers to leave product reviews or store ratings, encourage them to post photos or videos featuring the product on social media under a branded hashtag, and even invite them to refer friends and family to earn points.

This phase also presents the ideal moment to guide customers into higher VIP tiers. Rather than having customers continually earn points without experiencing any alteration in rewards, brands can use tiers to make loyal shoppers feel more valued with bigger and better incentives. This could include perks such as free shipping and birthday gifts for middle-tier customers and above, or hosting exclusive events and private sales for customers in the top tier.

A culture of acknowledgment and recognition throughout the retention stage is crucial for nurturing enduring customer relationships. According to 57% of brand executives, the primary objective in investing in customer loyalty strategies is the establishment of emotional connections with customers.

Maximize Customer Loyalty and Engagement with Stamped

For e-commerce brands eyeing robust growth, the focus must shift towards customer retention, rather than resting solely on customer acquisition. Fortunately, numerous strategies exist for nurturing customer loyalty, each capable of adaptation according to a brand’s unique resources, capabilities, and goals.

Stamped offers a comprehensive solution that encompasses reviews, referrals, user-generated content, actionable insights, rewards programs, and more. These tools can collectively aid in building deeper, more meaningful relationships with customers. Brands can further explore these possibilities by scheduling a demo with one of Stamped’s sales representatives.

In an era where customers wield unprecedented power and countless options lie at their fingertips, customer loyalty is the cornerstone upon which businesses can thrive, evolve, and endure. It’s not just a fleeting notion; it’s the very lifeblood that courses through the veins of sustainable, successful e-commerce ventures.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *